“The Constitutional Court ruling on section 12 of the Divorce Act 70 1979 is a victory for media freedom and children’s rights to dignity and privacy.” Said William Bird, director of Media Monitoring Africa (MMA).
Represented by the Centre for Child Law, MMA joined as an Amicus Curiae (friend of the court) in a case involving Johncom Media, the Minister of Justice and others, that sought to have section 12 of the Divorce Act declared unconstitutional.
The Constitutional Court made an order that does not unduly favour either the media or the litigant. It stated, “Subject to authorisation granted by a court in exceptional circumstances, the publication of the identity of, and any information that may reveal the identity of, any party or child in any divorce proceedings before any court is prohibited.” (Con. Court Ruling, Justice Jafta 45.2 p.21)
The impact of this is that media can now freely report on divorce matters and reveal as much detail as necessary for their stories. The only limitation is around naming or identifying the parties involved. In all cases children’s names and identities, as well as those of the parents involved will need to be protected. Unless there are exceptional circumstances and media successfully apply for an order to publish the names and identities of those involved, any media story on divorce proceedings that reveals the name and or identity of any of the parties involved either directly or indirectly will amount to contempt of court.
To this extent the order of the court has resulted in a situation which is the reverse of Section 12 i.e. media can now report all the detail they wish, which is in line with the argument presented by Johncom and supported by MMA, as a means of informing and educating the public about divorce matters, but unless there are exceptional circumstances they may not name or identify the people involved. While some may argue that this element that extends to adults undermines media freedom, it could also, as was the case with the court, be seen as a case of seeking to protect the privacy of the individuals involved. Divorce can make for exciting gossip and while it may be interesting to the public, in many cases it would be difficult to argue that it is in the public interest to know who is involved in divorce proceedings. It should be noted that where there is a clear public interest in a particular case, the media would be encouraged to apply for an order enabling media to name the parties involved and MMA would clearly support media in such cases.
Not only does the ruling highlight the importance of media freedom and children’s rights but it also has the effect of requiring greater legal and ethical adherence to reporting not only on children, but also more broadly on areas that are normally private and personal by nature. Given recent debates around the right to privacy versus public right to know it seems clear that the court has ruled that in personal matters of divorce there is a greater emphasis on the right to privacy.
Bird said, “The law as it stood was clearly untenable”, adding, “The media were allowed to name people involved in divorce cases, but were prevented from revealing the details.” In presenting the case, all parties agreed that Section12 was overly broad and violated South Africa’s press freedom clause, as well as the general rule of open reporting on court cases. MMA, represented in Constitutional Court by the Centre for Child Law, raised the vital issue of the importance of protecting children’s rights to dignity and privacy in divorce matters.
Children a special case?
It is important to consider that children are afforded special protection in a wide range of areas. There is a UN Convention dedicated to promoting and protecting children’s rights, as well as various other international laws. South Africa’s Bill of Rights has a special section dedicated to children, and South Africa has also recently just passed one of the most progressive pieces of legislations specifically targeting the protection of children, the Children’s Act. Parliament is now in the process of finalising the Child Justice Bill.
Special considerations apply to children in almost every aspect of a democratic society, from court to criminal procedures, from education to social grants and protection. But what about the media?
Children are also afforded specific protection in South African law in relation to media under the Criminal Procedure Act, as well as various other pieces of legislation. In these respects, the laws serve to protect children’s best interests by preventing the publication of their details, particularly in criminal matters.
Indications are that media in South Africa are becoming increasingly aware that reporting on children and child related matters are not only central to any news agenda, but also that reporting on children requires special attention and adherence to higher standards of journalistic practice. In this context it is extremely significant that the South African National Editors Forum (SANEF) has recommended guidelines for reporting on children developed by MMA to all its members. While the ethics surrounding reporting children are challenging, what is clear is that we all have an obligation to act in the best interest of the child.
The Constitutional Court agreed with MMA’s view and in the judgement went so far as to note, “the amicus subsequently submitted very helpful written and oral argument. We are indebted to the amicus for its important contribution.” (Con. Court Ruling, Justice Jafta 16 p.7)
———————————-
For more details, questions or comments
Contact
William Bird
Director
Media Monitoring Africa
Tel: 011 788 1278
Mob 082 887 1370
Email: williamb@mma.org.za
Or
Ann Skelton
Centre for Child Law
Tel: 012 346 0505
Mob: 082 443 2702
Emailnn.skelton@up.ac.za
order fenofibrate 200mg tricor cheap cheap tricor 160mg
zaditor us doxepin generic order imipramine sale
buy tadalafil 20mg pill sildenafil 100mg tablets sildenafil pill
buy generic precose 25mg griseofulvin 250mg tablet griseofulvin uk
purchase minoxidil solution mintop cost men’s ed pills
buy aspirin 75 mg without prescription generic hydroquinone zovirax creams
dipyridamole us dipyridamole 100mg without prescription buy generic pravachol online
buy meloset 3 mg generic melatonin 3mg brand danocrine 100mg generic
order fludrocortisone 100 mcg without prescription order fludrocortisone 100 mcg online cost loperamide
prasugrel 10 mg cost dimenhydrinate 50mg drug tolterodine 2mg ca
buy generic etodolac for sale buy colospa 135mg cilostazol 100mg cost
ferrous 100mg pill ascorbic acid 500 mg price betapace ca
brand vasotec buy enalapril online cheap purchase duphalac bottles
buy mestinon pills pyridostigmine 60mg uk buy generic rizatriptan online
betahistine 16mg sale benemid uk buy benemid 500 mg generic
how to get xalatan without a prescription generic xeloda 500mg cheap rivastigmine
buy omeprazole 20mg sale prilosec us lopressor usa
premarin order oral premarin 0.625mg viagra 50mg without prescription
telmisartan 80mg over the counter plaquenil 200mg uk buy molnunat pills
buy cenforce 100mg buy cenforce aralen price
otc cialis us cialis order viagra for sale
how to buy omnicef buy lansoprazole 15mg pills buy prevacid generic
modafinil order online order prednisone 5mg sale deltasone 5mg cost
order isotretinoin purchase amoxil order zithromax pills
order generic atorvastatin norvasc 5mg usa amlodipine sale
order azipro 500mg online cheap buy prednisolone sale gabapentin 100mg brand
protonix 20mg usa order protonix 20mg generic oral pyridium 200 mg
free casino games buy furosemide diuretic furosemide price
play roulette free for fun empire casino online albuterol 2mg oral
order amantadine 100mg pill atenolol oral avlosulfon 100 mg sale
free casino slot games blackjack card game buy levothyroxine generic
order medrol pills adalat drug aristocort price
clomiphene 50mg for sale where can i buy imdur purchase azathioprine
purchase vardenafil online cheap order digoxin for sale buy tizanidine pill
purchase perindopril pill clarinex 5mg sale order allegra 120mg online cheap
oral phenytoin 100 mg buy phenytoin 100 mg online cheap order ditropan 2.5mg for sale
buy loratadine 10mg generic order claritin generic order dapoxetine 90mg pills
order baclofen toradol order buy cheap generic ketorolac
purchase ozobax pills baclofen 25mg us buy toradol no prescription
amaryl 4mg pills order misoprostol 200mcg pill buy arcoxia cheap
buy generic alendronate fosamax oral buy macrodantin generic
inderal 20mg price buy propranolol pills for sale buy clopidogrel tablets
pamelor order online buy pamelor 25 mg panadol oral
order orlistat 60mg generic cheap mesalamine 400mg purchase diltiazem online cheap
warfarin 2mg cost reglan 20mg tablet buy reglan
oral astelin 10ml buy generic acyclovir irbesartan for sale
order esomeprazole 20mg generic oral mirtazapine topamax ca
buy allopurinol 300mg purchase clobetasol for sale crestor 20mg without prescription
sumatriptan 50mg cheap sumatriptan 50mg cheap buy avodart 0.5mg online
generic buspirone ezetimibe order online cordarone order
order ranitidine 150mg online cheap celecoxib medication celebrex 200mg cheap
buy domperidone generic order generic tetracycline buy tetracycline online
buy tamsulosin 0.2mg generic purchase simvastatin for sale buy generic simvastatin over the counter
assignment sites buy an assignment my future essay writing
order spironolactone 25mg without prescription spironolactone 100mg oral order proscar 1mg sale
buy sildenafil pill aurogra for sale buy generic estrace for sale
order lamotrigine for sale lamotrigine drug order nemazole pill
cheap flagyl 400mg purchase keflex online cheap order keflex pill
retin usa retin gel for sale avanafil where to buy
clindamycin drug clindamycin cheap non prescription ed pills
buy tadalafil 10mg without prescription buy indocin 75mg generic indocin cheap
buy nolvadex 10mg without prescription cost nolvadex order symbicort without prescription
cost axetil buy careprost eye drops order robaxin generic
terbinafine 250mg canada gamble with real money online casino moons online casino
desyrel tablet clindamycin brand buy clindac a paypal
order essays online essay writing university cheap suprax 200mg
where to buy aspirin without a prescription chumba online real money casinos online casino
help with assignments australia my father essay writing slot games online
order trimox arimidex drug clarithromycin 500mg pill
generic calcitriol 0.25mg how to get rocaltrol without a prescription tricor 200mg drug
catapres 0.1mg over the counter order clonidine spiriva 9 mcg sale
What is SightCare? Sight Care is an amazing supplement that promotes healthy eyesight and reduces dark blindness using natural ingredients.
adult acne medication at ulta teenage acne treatments that work oxcarbazepine us
order minocin generic minocin 50mg usa order ropinirole 2mg without prescription
cost letrozole 2.5mg buy albendazole 400mg generic order abilify 20mg generic
buy sleeping tablets online uk strongest sleeping pills for adults online prescriptions weight loss medication
nhs stop smoking clinic online physician consultation pain medication order pain medication online prescription
cymbalta 40mg tablet provigil ca modafinil for sale online
buy lamisil tablets online herpes medication to prevent spreading 10 best blood pressure medicines
generic promethazine medications for ed how much is ivermectin
is a duodenal ulcer dangerous protective medication for ulcers uti treatment guidelines for elderly
purchase prednisone online oral prednisone 10mg buy amoxil generic
online birth control prescription services how to last longer exercise how to last longer in bed exercises
generic azithromycin 250mg zithromax 500mg tablet neurontin usa
losec 20mg omeprazole sandoz best medication to stop vomiting does imodium stop farting
actigall 150mg canada ursodiol 150mg ca zyrtec 5mg oral