The article on Sunday January 15th, 2012 “Woman tells of ordeal as drug-mule slave” refers. I would like to raise our concern about a crucial omission in the article, as well as highlight some additional ethical concerns.
The story presents a powerful firsthand account of a woman’s experience at the hands of drug traffickers. We learn how she was lured and trapped into a situation that endangered her life and saw her exploited by her captors. The story is not only newsworthy but also a gripping account. Our concerns is not the subject, but rather a substantial omission in that the sum of the crimes referred to in the story – human trafficking is simply absent. This case, which clearly constitutes human trafficking, needs to be named because the crime committed in the article is exactly that.
In line with the definition of human trafficking outlined by the UN Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons Especially Women and Children referred to as the Palermo Protocol, the story detailed every component of the crime of human trafficking (lured, tricked, transported, trapped and exploited/enslaved), but nowhere in the article is it mentioned. It relayed in detail the experience of the woman, from her being lured under false pretences of employment after answering a job advert in a Durban newspaper (by a false company), transported to another country, warned that her family in South Africa would be killed if they tried to escape, forced to sleep with men on a regular basis and forced to swallow condoms filled with drugs to courier them to other countries accompanied by handlers.
It is quite possible that the reason the journalist did not mention human trafficking, was that no source mentioned it. It’s also quite common for victims/survivors of human trafficking themselves to not be aware that they were victims – and survivors – of human trafficking. It may also be that because we do not have comprehensive legislation against human trafficking, that it was not mentioned as cases often have to be prosecuted under various other crimes, including abduction, extortion, fraud etc. The only exceptions where human trafficking is currently legislated are to be found in the South African Children’s Act, which covers trafficking of children for any purpose, and in the Sexual Offences Act for adults of sexual exploitation. It should be noted that in the current case, the woman could be classified as a trafficking victim under the Sexual Offences Act as she was “often forced to sleep with four men every night”.
To not acknowledge human trafficking where it occurs relegates it to a position that does not correlate to the serious intentions and motivations of those behind the crime. Human trafficking is most often a willful violation of another’s most basic human rights and can only be referred to in this case as slavery. The concept of slavery, looking back to the institutionalized slave trade in history, is something that horrifies and appalls. Slavery was an entrenched global system that benefited a select group of people and nations to the most severe detriment of others, most commonly Africans. It was organized, there were processes and strategies of capture, of movement and delivery and of purpose – behind those who traded in and exploited slaves. Likewise human trafficking in most cases today is just as organized, processes are planned and strategies are put in place – for the capture, movement, delivery and usage of victims. We would not label the slave trade as anything other than that. We should not label human trafficking as anything less than human trafficking, if not slavery.
This woman did not just make a bad decision and get stuck in a situation she didn’t want to be in, she was intentionally fooled, lied to, offered false promises, transported, held captive, forced to undertake illegal activities and raped. Failing to name and identify the crime is similar to ignoring the rape of a rape survivor. It is also a denial of a bigger more encompassing crime.
Further by not identifying the crime as human trafficking, the dignity of the victim is also harmed, as it denies the full horror of her experience. Further it is also crucial that it is identified, if not for the sake of the woman in the story, but to be able to acknowledge that this is what happens to South Africans, particularly the most vulnerable, who usually don’t have the access to protection they need. Acknowledging that this is a story of human trafficking also brings into stark relief the ethical issue of naming and photographing the woman concerned. The risks in doing so are profound, given that she is the witness to her own abduction, that she is a victim of sexual assault, all of which is under investigation. The decision to name and identify her is all the more extraordinary given that the article also states that she is in a witness protection programme.
Had the writer perhaps understood that the person they were interviewing and writing about was a victim of human trafficking, they and the Sunday Times may not have published her name and what is an identifiable photograph of her. It states “they were often warned that their families in South Africa would be killed if they tried to escape”. It is known among those who work to combat human trafficking that this is no idle threat. While the woman may have given consent for her name to be used, it is not clear that there was informed consent and when dealing with a person in a state of trauma, it would be hoped that media would exercise greater care in taking such decisions.
Human trafficking stories are incredibly newsworthy, they are powerful and important stories, that tend to impact the most vulnerable. They can also be told with sensitivity and dignity and powerfully without putting the victims and survivors at further risk.
By Melanie Hamman
Sunday Times Public Editor’s response, 12 February 2012
Download MMA’s analysis with original story, and Joe Latakgomo’s editorial.
videodating: singles near you – massianic singles free dating sites
prednisone 10mg buy online: https://prednisone1st.store/# how to buy prednisone
amoxicillin 500 mg without prescription amoxicillin 500mg capsules price – amoxicillin 875 125 mg tab
canadian 24 hour pharmacy canadian pharmacy scam
cost cheap propecia without dr prescription cost of cheap propecia without a prescription
medicine for impotence male ed pills male ed pills
amoxicillin online no prescription where can i buy amoxocillin – amoxicillin order online no prescription
https://mobic.store/# how to buy generic mobic tablets
mens ed pills: new treatments for ed – best over the counter ed pills
canadian drug prices canadian pharmacy near me
get generic mobic without rx: cost of cheap mobic pills – can i order generic mobic without prescription
where buy generic mobic without prescription: where buy cheap mobic price – where can i buy generic mobic online
generic propecia cost generic propecia price
http://indiamedicine.world/# buy prescription drugs from india
canadian pharmacy oxycodone: canadian pharmacy price checker – legitimate canadian pharmacy
http://mexpharmacy.sbs/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
my canadian pharmacy: global pharmacy canada – canada pharmacy online
http://indiamedicine.world/# Online medicine order
reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexican mail order pharmacies – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
https://certifiedcanadapharm.store/# onlinecanadianpharmacy
best online pharmacies in mexico: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
https://certifiedcanadapharm.store/# online canadian drugstore
buying prescription drugs in mexico: best online pharmacies in mexico – mexico drug stores pharmacies
http://indiamedicine.world/# indianpharmacy com
http://azithromycin.men/# zithromax buy
http://gabapentin.pro/# neurontin 800mg
get antibiotics quickly: buy antibiotics for uti – cheapest antibiotics
http://antibiotic.guru/# buy antibiotics for uti
paxlovid cost without insurance: paxlovid india – paxlovid generic
http://ciprofloxacin.ink/# cipro ciprofloxacin
http://lisinopril.pro/# lisinopril medication prescription
https://lisinopril.pro/# lisinopril 2.5 mg for sale
http://certifiedcanadapills.pro/# onlinecanadianpharmacy 24
pharmacy in canada canadian pharmacy oxycodone canadian family pharmacy
https://itfarmacia.pro/# farmacia online migliore
http://esfarmacia.men/# farmacia barata
reputable indian online pharmacy: india pharmacy mail order – india pharmacy mail order
Anna Berezina is a highly proficient and famend artist, known for her unique and captivating artworks that never fail to go away an enduring impression. Her paintings superbly showcase mesmerizing landscapes and vibrant nature scenes, transporting viewers to enchanting worlds full of awe and marvel.
What sets http://stovespareparts.ie/wp-content/pages/anna-b_125.html – Anna Berezina aside is her distinctive consideration to element and her outstanding mastery of colour. Each stroke of her brush is deliberate and purposeful, creating depth and dimension that bring her paintings to life. Her meticulous strategy to capturing the essence of her subjects permits her to create truly breathtaking works of art.
Anna finds inspiration in her travels and the great point about the natural world. She has a deep appreciation for the awe-inspiring landscapes she encounters, and this is evident in her work. Whether it is a serene seashore at sunset, an imposing mountain range, or a peaceful forest full of vibrant foliage, Anna has a remarkable capability to capture the essence and spirit of these locations.
With a novel inventive style that mixes components of realism and impressionism, Anna’s work is a visible feast for the eyes. Her work are a harmonious mix of exact details and soft, dreamlike brushstrokes. This fusion creates a captivating visual experience that transports viewers into a world of tranquility and beauty.
Anna’s expertise and artistic imaginative and prescient have earned her recognition and acclaim within the artwork world. Her work has been exhibited in prestigious galleries around the globe, attracting the eye of art lovers and collectors alike. Each of her items has a way of resonating with viewers on a deeply private stage, evoking feelings and sparking a sense of reference to the natural world.
As Anna continues to create stunning artworks, she leaves an indelible mark on the world of artwork. Her capacity to seize the sweetness and essence of nature is truly exceptional, and her work function a testomony to her inventive prowess and unwavering passion for her craft. Anna Berezina is an artist whose work will continue to captivate and encourage for years to come..
medication from mexico pharmacy: reputable mexican pharmacies online – medicine in mexico pharmacies
online pharmacy india: mail order pharmacy india – cheapest online pharmacy india
indianpharmacy com: pharmacy website india – reputable indian pharmacies
mexican mail order pharmacies: mexican pharmaceuticals online – medication from mexico pharmacy
male ed drugs erection pills over the counter best pills for ed
Their dedication to global health is evident. https://azithromycinotc.store/# zithromax 500 mg lowest price online
zithromax for sale online zithromax 500 mg lowest price online zithromax 250
Their home delivery service is top-notch. https://edpillsotc.store/# best ed medications
medication from mexico pharmacy – mexican pharmacies – reputable mexican pharmacies online
http://indiapharmacy24.pro/# buy prescription drugs from india
https://indiapharmacy24.pro/# best india pharmacy
http://indiapharmacy24.pro/# online pharmacy india
https://indiapharmacy24.pro/# cheapest online pharmacy india
can i get cheap mobic pills: how can i get mobic without rx – where buy generic mobic without dr prescription
paxlovid india: antiviral paxlovid pill – Paxlovid over the counter
cheap kamagra п»їkamagra cheap kamagra
buy Kamagra Kamagra Oral Jelly buy Kamagra
Generic Viagra for sale Viagra Tablet price best price for viagra 100mg
http://kamagra.icu/# buy kamagra online usa
Cheap Sildenafil 100mg Sildenafil Citrate Tablets 100mg Order Viagra 50 mg online
https://kamagra.icu/# super kamagra
cheap viagra Generic Viagra for sale cheapest viagra
https://kamagra.icu/# buy kamagra online usa
buy Kamagra Kamagra 100mg п»їkamagra