It is our shared view that in terms of Section 12 of the Competition Act, the deal entered into between the SABC and Multichoice, in which Multichoice acquired control over part of the SABC business, constitutes a mandatory notifiable merger. We are not aware of any attempt to notify the Competition Tribunal of such a merger. If the deal is proven to be a notifiable merger it will enable us to oppose the merger on the basis that it is not in the public interest for it to take place.
When news of the deal broke in 2013, both MMA and SOS expressed deep concern as to the nature of the deal. We both believe it fundamentally works against the best and long term interests of the SABC and the people it serves.
We have three main concerns with the deal:
Handing over the SABC archive: In entering the deal, the SABC has handed over power and control of its archives to Multichoice. The archives are more than simply a collection of old broadcast programmes and material, they are an invaluable public asset, of a broadcaster that has unique footage of South Africa’s transition to a democracy, including unique footage of Mandela. As we head (albeit ever so slowly) into a digital environment, content is as gold to a jeweller. In giving control and access of the archive to a commercial player SABC has sold off the family jewels.
Encryption turnaround: It is our view that the SABC effectively ceded its power to determine its policy on set-top box control to a commercial broadcasting entity that is also its competitor. The deal required that the SABC change its original policy of supporting encryption on set-top boxes. The SABC acceded to this in spite of the significant benefits such encryption would have for free-to-air broadcasters, including itself, in terms of giving it a competitive edge against their biggest rival – Multichoice’s DStv. The questions that arise are: who benefits from such a turn around, and is it in the best interest of the SABC for it to have, at Multichoice’s behest, done a u-turn on the decision to oppose encryption on set-top boxes? We believe it is not in the SABC’s best interests and it seems the issue – which might otherwise seem out of place in the agreement was inserted to support Multichoice’s case against encryption.
Best programming veto: In addition to the handing over of the SABC archive, the deal also sets out terms for a future channel to be developed by the SABC, in terms of which Multichoice may veto some programmes and select only the best ones to be broadcast exclusively on the SABC-Multichoice platform. In so doing, not only does the deal ensure the best future local programming is aired on its platform it also means citizens who do not subscribe to the Multichoice services will be denied viewing the programming – ensuring the most marginalised and poor citizens are deprived of quality content. This clearly goes against the public interest mandate of the SABC.
While the issue of the merger overtly targets the issue of control of the archive we believe that it will help raise broader issues relating to the digital terrestrial television (DTT) set-top box encryption debate as well as enabling a broader conversation about content on the public broadcaster in a digital environment.
How did we come get to be involved? As two organisations whose work around public interest programming and broadcasting is well known and respected, Caxton approached us to join an application they were bringing. We realised that on the issue of the deal, we found common agreement. We know that in other circumstances and on other issues we may strongly disagree with Caxton, (including for example Transformation in the media), as on other issues we may agree equally or strongly disagree with the SABC and/or Multichoice. In the current circumstance, joining the application has enabled us to take forward a clear public interest issue and address what is in our view fundamentally a bad deal.
For more contact:
William Bird (MMA): 082 887 1370
Sekoetlane Phamodi (SOS): 076 084 8077
About MMA: Media Monitoring Africa (MMA) started in 1993 and is a non-profit organisation that aims to promote democracy and a culture where media and the powerful respect human rights and encourage a just and fair society.
About SOS: The SOS Coalition represents a broad spectrum of civil society stakeholders committed to the broadcasting of quality, diverse, citizen-orientated public-interest programming aligned to the goals of the South African Constitution. The Coalition includes a number of trade union federations including COSATU and FEDUSA, a number of independent unions including BEMAWU and MWASA; independent film and TV production sector organisations including the South African Screen Federation (SASFED); a host of NGOs and CBOs including the Freedom of Expression Institute (FXI), Media Monitoring Africa (MMA), SECTION27 and a number of academics and freedom of expression activists.
]]>
tricor brand tricor over the counter fenofibrate 160mg brand
buy minoxytop generic tamsulosin brand ed pills that work quickly
acarbose over the counter fulvicin 250 mg generic order griseofulvin online
aspirin 75 mg price aspirin 75mg tablet imiquimod medication
buy dipyridamole 100mg online brand pravastatin 20mg order generic pravachol 20mg
buy meloset 3mg without prescription aygestin tablet order danocrine 100mg sale
dydrogesterone 10mg ca sitagliptin 100 mg pill buy jardiance 25mg online
buy florinef cheap buy aciphex 10mg generic loperamide 2mg tablet
purchase etodolac online cilostazol 100mg tablet cilostazol order
buy prasugrel 10 mg without prescription buy dramamine 50mg online tolterodine order online
order ferrous sulfate 100mg for sale buy ferrous 100mg for sale buy betapace 40 mg online cheap
mestinon 60 mg cheap feldene 20 mg cost cost maxalt
enalapril 10mg us lactulose usa duphalac cost
xalatan where to buy rivastigmine canada order exelon
purchase betahistine pill probenecid sale buy probenecid cheap
order omeprazole 20mg generic order prilosec generic lopressor 100mg pills
buy premarin 600 mg generic premarin oral sildenafil for men
order telmisartan 80mg without prescription order generic molnupiravir 200 mg order generic molnupiravir 200mg
order tadalafil 5mg without prescription cialis for sale online buy sildenafil 50mg pills
buy cenforce 100mg generic purchase cenforce pill aralen 250mg cheap
cefdinir 300 mg for sale cost prevacid 15mg buy lansoprazole 30mg without prescription
order modafinil pills order modafinil 100mg order prednisone 10mg
accutane 10mg usa order isotretinoin 10mg online generic azithromycin 250mg
buy atorvastatin without a prescription buy proventil 100mcg generic amlodipine 10mg pill
purchase azithromycin generic order prednisolone 5mg generic cost neurontin
free spins play online roulette for fun order furosemide online
buy generic protonix 20mg phenazopyridine canada buy pyridium 200mg sale
Awesome article.
free slot card games online albuterol inhaler
Excellent article! We are linking to this partcularly
great contenjt on oour website. Keepp up the gokod writing.
Today, I went to thhe beach ith my kids. I found a seea shelll andd gave iit
too myy 4 year olld ddaughter and ssid “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She puut the shell to heer
eaar and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and itt pinched
hher ear. Shhe nwver wants too go back! LoL I khow
his is entirely offf tooic but I hadd too tell someone!
amantadine cost symmetrel 100 mg oral dapsone 100 mg cost
best real casino online stromectol without prescription buy ivermectin 3 mg for humans
real money games where can i buy synthroid synthroid price
clomiphene generic buy imdur 20mg generic order azathioprine 50mg pill
order levitra 10mg without prescription levitra over the counter how to buy zanaflex
order aceon 8mg buy desloratadine 5mg for sale allegra 180mg uk
buy phenytoin online cheap dilantin 100mg pill brand oxybutynin 2.5mg
order loratadine generic order dapoxetine 30mg order generic priligy 30mg
order lioresal generic ozobax pills order toradol for sale
order ozobax pill buy ketorolac without prescription toradol 10mg tablet
brand glimepiride glimepiride over the counter buy etoricoxib without a prescription
buy alendronate 35mg for sale buy cheap generic nitrofurantoin purchase furadantin generic
inderal without prescription order inderal 10mg online cheap clopidogrel for sale
nortriptyline 25mg ca buy methotrexate tablets order anacin pill
buy orlistat 60mg xenical 120mg usa diltiazem 180mg pills
buy generic medex order generic paroxetine 10mg buy maxolon pill
buy azelastine 10 ml generic azelastine sprayers order irbesartan 300mg without prescription
pepcid 40mg over the counter pepcid 20mg cost purchase prograf without prescription
esomeprazole capsules nexium capsules cost topiramate 100mg
order allopurinol pill temovate for sale online crestor over the counter
imitrex 25mg oral buy imitrex 50mg avodart price
purchase zantac pill order ranitidine 300mg sale order celebrex 200mg
order domperidone 10mg online motilium 10mg sale sumycin 250mg price
buy tamsulosin ondansetron online order order simvastatin 10mg generic
assignment company paperwriter writing dissertation service
cost sildenafil purchase sildalis sale buy estrace pill
purchase forcan generic buy generic ampicillin 500mg ciprofloxacin 500mg ca
where can i buy flagyl metronidazole 400mg ca cephalexin 125mg oral
where to buy lamictal without a prescription buy lamotrigine tablets how to buy nemazole
buy cleocin 300mg sale buy erythromycin home remedies for ed erectile dysfunction
how to buy tretinoin buy stendra pills order avana 200mg pill
Great blog here! Also youhr site loaads up fast! Whatt web hosdt
are yyou using? Can I get yojr affilliate link too your host?
I wish mmy web sife loaded uup ass quijckly as yours
lol
tadacip 10mg without prescription tadalafil sale indomethacin medication
oral cefuroxime 500mg cefuroxime 250mg uk robaxin online buy
order terbinafine for sale slots games free real money slots free spins no deposit
order aspirin 75mg sale slot online sugarhouse casino online
help with my assignment design thesis proposal suprax over the counter
help me with my research paper free slots best casino games
order amoxicillin for sale buy generic biaxin clarithromycin 250mg over the counter
calcitriol 0.25mg for sale buy trandate generic purchase tricor pill
purchase minomycin generic buy hytrin cheap ropinirole pills
order uroxatral generic purchase alfuzosin heartburn medication new warnings
order generic femara 2.5 mg aripiprazole 30mg tablet buy aripiprazole generic
strongest sleeping pills for adults can online doctor prescribe ambien prescription strength diet pills online
generic provera biltricide 600mg over the counter microzide us
nicotine replacement calculator chemotherapy for bone marrow cancer pain killers well known
periactin 4 mg tablet order fluvoxamine 100mg generic order ketoconazole 200 mg for sale
best way to treat herpes buy inhalers for asthma online type 2 diabetes develops if