Every Monday morning Media Monitoring Africa (MMA) staff meets to discuss and analyse examples of the best and worst media coverage of children. Each week we select one example of the worst reporting for a MAD, and one example of the best reporting for a GLAD. However, last week we had more than 10 MADS – that is, examples of reporting that clearly violated a number of children’s rights outlined in the South African Constitution and provided for in the SANEF recommended guidelines for reporting on children. It has become nearly impossible to pick one example out of so many, which is why MMA felt compelled to write MADS about multiple articles.
This week was no different. Again, more than a dozen articles were nominated for a MAD from the following newspapers (in alphabetical order): The Citizen, Daily Sun, Mail & Guardian, The New Age, Sowetan and The Star. Such was the severity of the children’s rights abuses in each of these articles that MMA felt compelled to combine them all in another MEGA MAD. We hope this raises awareness and encourages better reporting behaviour.
The Citizen
“Day-care assault charge laid” (The Citizen, 18/01/2011, p. 4) – an eight-month-old baby who was abused while in a day-care centre, was named and pictured with her parents, and therefore directly identified by the newspaper. The article also described in detail her abuse and type of injuries sustained. Identifying an abused child violates their rights and isn’t in the best interest of the child. The description of her abuse is gratuitous. It is the journalist’s role to protect the child and furthermore, inform the parents of their obligation to protect their child’s identity. Ironically, the article didn’t identify the abuser or the day-care centre where the abuse took place.
A day later, in “Day mother blamed over alleged child abuse” (The Citizen, 19/01/2011, p. 6 the same mistakes were repeated. The abused child is named and her injuries described in detail. However MMA would like to give credit to the journalist for referring to the Children’s Act and explaining how the law was violated in this case.
Daily Sun
“Army Dad goes mad!” (Daily Sun, 17/01/2011, p. 5) – interviewed and indirectly identified a ten year old boy who witnessed his father kill his grandmother and aunt before killing himself. The article named the child’s father, mother, grandmother and aunt, and therefore indirectly identified him. According to section 154(3) of the Criminal Procedure Act “no person shall publish in any manner whatever information which reveals or may reveal the identity… of a witness at criminal proceedings who is under the age of 18 years.” Aside from being a child witness to a crime, this child was forced to relive his traumatic experience just three days after it happened. This child’s welfare was sacrificed for the sake of tabloid sensationalist journalism.
“Spinning Death” (Daily Sun, 17/01/2011, p. 4 – identified and pictured a four year old child who witnessed an accident involving a spinning car in which his uncle was killed. The report confirmed that a case of culpable homicide had been opened. The boy is a child witness to a crime, and the law requires that his identity be protected. The article also reported that the uncle was attempting to protect the child who “likes to sneak out and watch the cars spinning.” Telling this story in this manner risks increasing the emotional trauma that this child may experience, either now or as he grows older. This child should be protected and supported, and not made feel guilty or responsible for the death of his uncle.
“Hot Klap” (Daily Sun, 19/01/2011, p. 5) named and photographed a seven year old boy who is experiencing temporary blindness after he was allegedly hit by a girl in school. Irrespective of the age of the accused, this child was an alleged victim of an assault. It is also possible that this child was a victim of bullying and highlighting the issue in this way may not have been in a child’s best interests.
“Back in Mum’s Arms” (Daily Sun, 19/01/2011, p. 3) was a follow on story from an article that earned a MAD the week before: “She stole R1,800 and ran!” (Daily Sun, 14/01/2011, p.15). The article was about a missing 11 year old girl but it focused on an allegation that she had stolen money from her mother and run away.
In the follow up article, which earns a second MAD, Daily Sun patted itself on the back for helping to re-unite the child with her mother. The child reportedly told her mother that she took the money in order to go and visit her grandmother, but that she got lost. She was then found by a woman, and she stayed with her until she was brought to a police station.
There were indications in the article that an awareness of the child carrying money may have created a potentially dangerous situation for her and her family. One person tried to extort money from the family, claiming they could return the child in exchange for R2,000. The child also alleges she was essentially exploited because of the money. Of the family who found her she said that “they only cared about the money I had and pretended to be helping me.” Even if this alleged exploitation did not happen as a result of the Daily Sun report, it highlights the potentially dangerous situation created by highlighting that a vulnerable child is in possession of a large sum of money.
Mail & Guardian
“A land that’s in need of a cure” (Mail & Guardian, 21/01/2011, p. 37) brought to our attention a central problem in Africa – malnutrition caused by inadequate access to health care services for pregnant mothers – told through a story of a mother and her malnourished one-year-old child in Southern Sudan, both of whom were named. While in contrast to other examples of poor reporting mentioned in this report this particular article was in fact well written and powerful, it is questionable whether identifying the mother and the child in the story was in their best interest. In addition, the article was accompanied by a stock photograph depicting a stereotypical image of a severely malnourished child, whom in this case isn’t even the child the story was about. The child in the photograph was a named and identified two-year-old girl from a different part of the country. While MMA understands the challenges involved in reporting from remote and international locations, possible alternatives were to publish a photograph in which the child isn’t identified and doesn’t reinforce stereotypes, or a photograph of the actual child and mother featured in the story, while keeping their identities concealed.
The New Age
In “Siamese twins’ mom needs help” (The New Age, 11/01/2011, p. 5) The New Age journalist appeared to have misunderstood what it means to protect the identity of a child. The article clearly stated that the teenage mother of conjoined twins “cannot be named because of her age.” However the article quoted and named her sister and guardian, thereby indirectly identifying the mother. It also named the child’s twins and published a photograph of them, despite the fact that their identities should also have been protected.
If a newspaper thinks it is appropriate to protect the identity of a child, simply omitting a name is not necessarily sufficient, especially where there is other information provided that will inevitably identify the person. In its guidelines Media Monitoring Africa (MMA) elaborates on this point saying: “to identify a child…means to provide the child’s name, or information about where the child lives, what school the child attends or any other indirect means where a child may be recognized by people who know the child.”
“Falling wall crushed three-year-old” (The New Age, 11/01/2011, p. 1) – on its front page The New Age chose to make two children who had witnessed the death of their cousin the face of the tragedy. The two young children were playing with their cousin when he was killed. The image of the two sad children was clearly intended to tug at the heart strings. However these children have just experienced an upsetting and emotional ordeal. This photograph was invasive, insensitive and at worst a cynical ploy to sell newspapers. By publishing it The New Age fails in its ethical obligation to minimise harm.
“Aids orphans’ boost by back-to-school project” (The New Age, 20/01/2011, p.27) – pictured and therefore identified children that were described as “Aids orphans.” The initiative in the article, where disadvantaged children are given free school uniforms, is of course a positive one. However by showing the faces of the children, who were defined in the article exclusively by virtue of the fact that they lost parents to HIV and Aids, it potentially undermined the positive nature of the story, and risked making the children more vulnerable and stigmatised in their communities. It is also worth noting that this was a local municipality’s “back-to school” project. Positive publicity for local government ahead of upcoming local elections should not come at the expense of children’s welfare.
MMA had a similar concern about “Bakkie kills girl two days into school” (The New Age, 17/01/2011, p. 25) in which a child witness to a crime was named and photographed alongside MEC Magome Masike. It also appeared that the photograph was supplied to the newspaper by the North Western Provincial Government. Here again the child’s identity should have been protected for ethical and legal reasons.
Sowetan
Front page articles “White school bars black child” (Sowetan, 14/01/2011, p. 1 and 4) and “Barred boy gets new school” (Sowetan, 18/01/2011, p. 1 and 2) named and pictured a 7-year-old boy who was told he couldn’t attend an Afrikaans-speaking school because he didn’t speak the language. The headline “White school bars black child” and “Black boy (7) chased away” (Sowetan, 14/01/2011, p. 4) made clear that the newspaper interpreted this story to be one of race. MMA strongly believes that a 7-year-old boy should not be made a poster boy for a race or language debate.
The Star
“Twin saw sister leap to death in front of train” (The Star, 20/01/201, p. 2) interviewed and identified (by name and in a photograph) the 17-year old twin sister of the victim who was also a witness to her suicide. In addition it identified their mother, where they live and their school. Identifying a minor in this case was not in the child’s best interest, and asking her to relive the experience of witnessing her sister’s suicide could potentially causes the child secondary trauma.
The article also missed the opportunity to expand on the counselling services available to students who may be struggling at school as well as for their parents who may need guidance on how to deal with this. This information was included only at the end of the article, whereas the story could have benefitted from choosing to make this educational and informative component the focus of the story.
Children are afforded special protection under international law and or constitution. There is a ministry dedicated to overseeing their wellbeing and numerous pieces of legislation that focus on children. In most of the instances above, the clear violation of children’s rights has little justification and seems largely gratuitous and self interested.
Currently our press code does NOT cover children except under the definition of child pornography.
By Sandra Banjac and Laura Fletcher
singles website for farmers: matchmaking dating – best datings sites
prednisone 15 mg daily: http://prednisone1st.store/# prednisone 20mg for sale
the canadian pharmacy onlinecanadianpharmacy 24
cost of cheap mobic no prescription: can you buy cheap mobic pill – get cheap mobic without insurance
canadian pharmacy ltd vipps approved canadian online pharmacy
buy generic propecia no prescription order cheap propecia prices
amoxicillin 500mg buy online uk: http://amoxicillins.com/# can we buy amoxcillin 500mg on ebay without prescription
77 canadian pharmacy trusted canadian pharmacy
natural remedies for ed: medication for ed dysfunction – non prescription ed drugs
https://mobic.store/# get generic mobic without a prescription
buy cheap propecia online cost of propecia without rx
mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexican mail order pharmacies – medication from mexico pharmacy
https://mexpharmacy.sbs/# mexican rx online
mexican pharmaceuticals online: best online pharmacies in mexico – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
https://indiamedicine.world/# indianpharmacy com
reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexican drugstore online – medication from mexico pharmacy
https://certifiedcanadapharm.store/# canadian pharmacy online store
canada rx pharmacy: canadian pharmacy near me – canadian pharmacy ltd
http://mexpharmacy.sbs/# mexican mail order pharmacies
https://certifiedcanadapharm.store/# canadian family pharmacy
indian pharmacy online: top online pharmacy india – Online medicine order
http://certifiedcanadapharm.store/# online pharmacy canada
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacy: canada pharmacy online – prescription drugs canada buy online
http://mexpharmacy.sbs/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
ivermectin 3mg tablets price: ivermectin drug – ivermectin 8 mg
http://stromectolonline.pro/# ivermectin topical
zithromax pill: zithromax coupon – zithromax 500 without prescription
http://stromectolonline.pro/# ivermectin oral 0 8
https://gabapentin.pro/# neurontin brand name 800 mg
https://antibiotic.guru/# buy antibiotics online
Paxlovid over the counter: paxlovid india – paxlovid for sale
https://avodart.pro/# can i get generic avodart pill
http://lisinopril.pro/# 16 lisinopril
http://misoprostol.guru/# buy cytotec online
http://misoprostol.guru/# cytotec online
https://avodart.pro/# order generic avodart prices
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexico drug stores pharmacies
http://indiapharmacy.cheap/# top online pharmacy india
https://indiapharmacy.cheap/# buy medicines online in india
http://itfarmacia.pro/# farmaci senza ricetta elenco
http://edpharmacie.pro/# Pharmacie en ligne fiable
buy medicines online in india: top online pharmacy india – india online pharmacy
Anna Berezina is a extremely gifted and famend artist, recognized for her unique and fascinating artworks that by no means fail to depart an enduring impression. Her work superbly showcase mesmerizing landscapes and vibrant nature scenes, transporting viewers to enchanting worlds crammed with awe and marvel.
What sets http://760display.com/wp-includes/pages/anna-b_127.html – Berezina apart is her distinctive attention to detail and her exceptional mastery of shade. Each stroke of her brush is deliberate and purposeful, creating depth and dimension that convey her work to life. Her meticulous strategy to capturing the essence of her subjects permits her to create actually breathtaking artworks.
Anna finds inspiration in her travels and the good thing about the pure world. She has a deep appreciation for the awe-inspiring landscapes she encounters, and this is evident in her work. Whether it’s a serene seaside at sundown, an impressive mountain vary, or a peaceable forest crammed with vibrant foliage, Anna has a outstanding capability to seize the essence and spirit of those locations.
With a novel inventive style that mixes parts of realism and impressionism, Anna’s work is a visual feast for the eyes. Her work are a harmonious mix of precise details and soft, dreamlike brushstrokes. This fusion creates a fascinating visible expertise that transports viewers right into a world of tranquility and sweetness.
Anna’s talent and creative vision have earned her recognition and acclaim within the artwork world. Her work has been exhibited in prestigious galleries around the globe, attracting the attention of artwork fanatics and collectors alike. Each of her items has a method of resonating with viewers on a deeply private stage, evoking emotions and sparking a way of connection with the pure world.
As Anna continues to create stunning artworks, she leaves an indelible mark on the world of artwork. Her capability to capture the sweetness and essence of nature is actually exceptional, and her paintings serve as a testomony to her creative prowess and unwavering ardour for her craft. Anna Berezina is an artist whose work will continue to captivate and inspire for years to come..
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: buying from online mexican pharmacy – mexican mail order pharmacies
canadian online drugstore: precription drugs from canada – pharmacy rx world canada
indianpharmacy com: top 10 online pharmacy in india – buy medicines online in india
indian pharmacy online: top online pharmacy india – indian pharmacy online
They bridge global healthcare gaps seamlessly. http://azithromycinotc.store/# purchase zithromax online
can you buy zithromax over the counter in mexico buy azithromycin over the counter generic zithromax medicine
Their senior citizen discounts are much appreciated. https://azithromycinotc.store/# zithromax 1000 mg pills
buy generic zithromax no prescription buy azithromycin over the counter buy zithromax without presc
A gem in our community. https://edpillsotc.store/# п»їerectile dysfunction medication
mexican mail order pharmacies or mexico pharmacy – purple pharmacy mexico price list
http://indiapharmacy24.pro/# reputable indian online pharmacy
http://indiapharmacy24.pro/# online pharmacy india
http://canadapharmacy24.pro/# canadianpharmacymeds
http://indiapharmacy24.pro/# п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
can you get cheap mobic for sale: buying generic mobic without rx – where buy generic mobic pills
mobic brand name: where can i buy mobic pill – can you get cheap mobic prices
Cheapest Sildenafil online buy Viagra over the counter Sildenafil 100mg price
http://levitra.eus/# Levitra 20 mg for sale
Kamagra 100mg cheap kamagra Kamagra 100mg price
п»їkamagra buy Kamagra Kamagra Oral Jelly
Cialis without a doctor prescription buy cialis pill Buy Tadalafil 5mg
https://kamagra.icu/# super kamagra
buy cialis pill Buy Tadalafil 20mg cheapest cialis
Buy Vardenafil online Levitra online pharmacy Cheap Levitra online
https://kamagra.icu/# sildenafil oral jelly 100mg kamagra
Vardenafil online prescription Buy Levitra 20mg online Buy Vardenafil online
The CBD SEO Agency delivers top-notch services quest of businesses in the thriving CBD industry. With a tactical propose to to Search Machine Optimization (SEO), they cbd seo company excel in enhancing online visibility and driving living traffic. Their expertise lies in tailoring SEO strategies specifically quest of CBD companies, navigating the unexcelled challenges of this niche market. Through wide keyword enquiry, content optimization, and link-building tactics, they effectively encouragement search rankings, ensuring clients stand inaccurate amidst competition. Their group’s dedication to staying updated with persistence trends and search engine algorithms ensures a lively and junk approach. The CBD SEO Agency’s commitment to transparency and customer communication fosters keeping and reliability. Overall, their specialized services pander to to the noticeable needs of CBD businesses, making them a valuable partner in navigating the digital aspect within this competitive market.