Support our media, pay subscriptions, write to journalists when they do well and also when they let you down, and most importantly remind people who trash out media that they may have their faults but our democracy would be a millions times poorer without them.
(William Bird)
On the downside, the following will all be familiar generalisations: Politicians and political parties lie, they treat citizens like we are idiots. When they should communicate they hide or are evasive, when caught with their hands in the cookie jar they instead try assure us that it wasn’t them. They are corrupt, and show total disdain for those who voted them into power. Media slip up or allow themselves to be used for others agendas, they are sloppy and unprofessional and think they are a law unto themselves.
While there is some truth to those generalisations, their main function is to serve as ammunition for media against political parties and vice versa. Crucially they undermine the actions of the politicians and those in government who do work extremely hard and tirelessly and deliver. Similarly, they make it only too easy to brush off the stellar work by journalists and media houses to help us understand events in our nation, and also expose wrongdoing.
There are a number of clear threats to media freedom in South Africa. We have witnessed an increase in direct threats to our journalists, in some cases by crowds, as we saw in a few instances during the #FeesMustFall protests, but also by private security where journalists have been physically removed from public areas and forced to delete images. There are also the gravel sinister and anti-democratic threats against journalists for uncovering things that some don’t wish to be uncovered. Most glaringly we have also seen threats against the SABC 8 simply for doing their job. What made these threats all the more concerning was the response by those in authority including the SABC itself and the Minister of communication, both seeking to downplay or ignore the threats and in so doing potentially implicating them in the deeds.
Other threats to media freedom include the reduction of quality and the number of journalists is a clear threat as it prevents stories from being told or being told fully. The commercial imperative and failing public broadcaster means limited audiences are targeted, and small commercial and community media struggle with sustainability. In addition to these threats there are potential threats posed by draft legislation. From the Cyber Security Bill, the Draft Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill as well as more recently, comments made by the Minister of State Security about the desire to regulate social media.
Perhaps one of the greatest emerging threats to our media freedom is that posed by fake news. To be clear fake news, is not new. People spreading lies dressed as news or using dramatic headlines to sell are old strategies. What is new, is our digital reality and social media where it is easy to invent spread and promote fake news. (Ironically this same ability can also be used to help spread and disseminate credible news). While fake news sounds like an easy concept, our reality means what’s true and what isn’t is often hard to determine. One of the ways we are currently approaching fake or dodgy news is instead to look at defining the positive, rather than the negative. In other words what constitutes trustworthy or credible news? We know where media are clear about their aims, where they have clear processes to ensure that what they tell us most of the time can be verified, that credible media subscribe to self and co-regulatory bodies. We know journalists who are credible tend to exist online, that they have a track record. It is easy for us having monitored media for over 24 years to know what more credible news looks like. The trick is to help ensure all of us can identify credible news, for once we know that, it then becomes a lot easier to also see what fake or dodgy news looks like.
There are generally two kinds of fake or dodgy news. The first as click bait to drive traffic to a fake or dodgy news site and where the content is still misleading and or doesn’t subscribe to common standards of journalism and then fake news done as part of a deliberate strategy to misinform and shift public discourse. Both are clear and present threats to media freedom, as they seek to mislead citizens and disempower them from being able to be informed and to participate meaningfully in society.
We are working on a number of plans to tackle both kinds using our existing and some tools in development. It is important for example to be aware that many of the fake/dodgy news sites copy from credible news sources in order to save the dodgy site work, but also to add a layer of credibility to the news story. So we are finding that many of the stories appearing on theses dodgy sites have as much as 50 to 60% of the actual story being copied from a legitimate news site. Of course no credit is given to the original source, but what the reader is then presented with is a half credible story.
Another area has recently emerged dealing with the impact of the dodgy sites on our most vulnerable members of society, our children. It is here that the real threat of dodgy news is made clear, but also the real strength and value of credible media and media freedom has for our society.
To be clear, traditional media often do not cover themselves in glory when it comes to reporting on children. Our research shows children are marginalised in news coverage. In other instances, traditional media violate the rights of children by identifying them when it is clearly not in their best interest to do so. In so doing, media show scant regard for their own ethics, co-regulatory bodies, their audiences and indeed the constitution which guarantees their very media freedom. This is why we have been working with media for over a decade to help improve their coverage and ethical reporting of children – and like many areas in our media there are significant positive shifts, but still a long way to go. But the point is however that through our MADS and GLADS, and direct interaction, we are able to engage directly with media, editors and journalists. Sometimes they may not like what we have to say but they are accountable and on those unusual occasions where we hit a dead end we go to the relevant self and co-regulatory bodies for relief. These are critical steps and issues for media freedom, for while media may get things wrong we can at least engage and hold them accountable and learn.
Not so easy for dodgy news sites. The issue is starkly illustrated in the wake of a video of a 14-year-old girl who engaged in sexual activity. It was clearly “child porn” or more accurately child sexual abuse imagery. When we were alerted to it via comments on social media we reported it immediately. YouTube to their credit removed the video within minutes. It demonstrated a real and meaningful response by a massive multinational. The humiliation for the girl sadly did not end there. When we did a search a few days later on the girl in the news tab on Google, the top ten results were all from dodgy news sites. Stories clearly fabricated, suggesting in separate stories that the girl’s mother and father had sought to end their lives. Another story suggested her boyfriend was 60 years old and had also sought to end his life by throwing himself from a building. No evidence as to the veracity of these stories was given, and ordinary citizens would hopefully have been able to see through the pieces as dodgy news. But still it got worse, for even though the video had been removed, the sites used clickbait to suggest that users could still watch the full unedited video. In other words, they were enticing their audiences to participate in viewing child sexual abuse.
There are a number of responses to this story. The first is that we cannot escape the fact that the child is from an under resourced family and background, so she doesn’t have the legal advice, or in some case necessary support structures to help her respond to the humiliation and violation of her right to dignity and privacy. We know that there have been similar incidents where child sexual abuse imagery was created at a private school where those images were not widely shared, and that those involved had the means and ability to deal with the negative consequences. So it matters that an already vulnerable member of society is made even more vulnerable merely because of her lack of resources.
There are also clearly legal implications to these dodgy sites soliciting audiences to watch child sexual abuse imagery. Doing so is a clear violation of the Film and Publications Amendment Act. As a result we sought to try and engage with the sites. We found it was incredibly difficult to find any name, and in the end we engaged with the website host of the sites. We sent them take down notices, which after some time they instructed their clients to remove the offending articles. This is a mixed success. It is positive that the most offensive stories were removed, but there is no level of accountability, or any guarantee that it will not happen again, and certainly no guarantee of redress for the young girl. Instead we saw on some other sites stories of another young girl who they said they had sexual footage of.
The third response is to the fact that while we do not know the circumstances around the story, or who shared the video, we do know that these dodgy sites sought to benefit from the violation of a child’s rights to dignity and privacy in the most crass and offensive manner. So in addition to having to deal with the fallout of the actual video that was shared, she is forced to endure the humiliation of ongoing stories about her, about her family’s shame and how they allegedly sought to take their own lives. In essence we have a group of people who, for commercial gain, further humiliate and violate the rights of a child who has already had her dignity and privacy violated in the most offensive and public of ways. These dodgy sites traded and benefitted directly from the misery and trauma of a vulnerable child. While we were able to get some of the other stories that were clearly illegal taken down, the others still remain, to the shame of the sites that host them. It seems difficult to conceive how much lower those behind these sites could stoop, than making money from the humiliation of a vulnerable child. Not only is it degrading behaviour, it also undermines media freedom in a profound manner.
Yes our more credible media get things wrong, sometimes badly, but they can be identified, engaged and held accountable. So next time you click on a story from a credible news source on Facebook or Twitter, appreciate that they have great media freedom but they are also responsible for what they produce. You too can also play your part, spot fake news and let us know about it @mediamattersZA Maybe you want to learn more about general social media safety, try out our online gamewith your children or learn the right online lingo through our Hashplay. In addition to these actions, support our media, pay subscriptions, write to journalists when they do well and also when they let you down, and most importantly remind people who trash out media that they may have their faults but our democracy would be a millions times poorer without them. DM
buy tricor 200mg generic buy tricor medication oral fenofibrate 160mg
Very amusing question
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Некулицы Иван github проекты
order ketotifen doxepin buy online order tofranil 25mg
buy minoxidil sale buy tamsulosin 0.4mg best ed pills non prescription uk
purchase acarbose griseofulvin 250 mg usa where to buy fulvicin without a prescription
buy aspirin 75 mg online buy zovirax online imiquad cream
buy meloset without a prescription buy aygestin 5 mg for sale buy danocrine without prescription
order dipyridamole generic pravastatin drug pravastatin order
buy dydrogesterone 10mg dydrogesterone 10mg generic jardiance for sale
fludrocortisone 100mcg for sale buy imodium online order loperamide
buy monograph no prescription monograph 600 mg generic pletal 100 mg usa
prasugrel over the counter order tolterodine 1mg sale how to get detrol without a prescription
where can i buy pyridostigmine order mestinon 60mg pills rizatriptan 5mg pills
You are not right. I am assured. Let’s discuss. Write to me in PM.
————
https://servers.expert/hoster/coopertinoru
ferrous sulfate cost buy actonel online cheap sotalol 40mg cost
enalapril 10mg pills vasotec 5mg drug buy lactulose generic
buy latanoprost for sale exelon tablet buy exelon 3mg without prescription
https://www.short4cams.com/
https://www.fap420.com/
In my opinion you commit an error. Let’s discuss it. Write to me in PM.
purchase premarin pills order dostinex for sale viagra 25mg for sale
Certainly. So happens. We can communicate on this theme.
——
https://rajabets-in-india.com/mobile-app/
buy prilosec for sale order omeprazole pills metoprolol 50mg usa
cialis next day delivery usa cheap sildenafil generic sildenafil 50mg tablets
micardis 80mg uk telmisartan uk buy generic movfor over the counter
buy generic cenforce online naprosyn 250mg usa buy chloroquine 250mg sale
buy provigil 100mg generic deltasone 5mg ca order generic prednisone 20mg
cefdinir 300mg drug order glucophage 1000mg pills prevacid online buy
order absorica online order accutane 40mg online azithromycin 250mg generic
buy azithromycin 250mg pills omnacortil 5mg cheap gabapentin 800mg price
lipitor 80mg pill amlodipine 5mg for sale norvasc ca
blackjack poker online free online blackjack generic lasix 40mg
play poker online for real money where can i play poker online purchase albuterol without prescription
pantoprazole 20mg tablet prinivil pills order pyridium 200mg for sale
blackjack games stromectol 6mg sale ivermectin 3mg
gambling game purchase levoxyl for sale synthroid 75mcg us
buy amantadine 100 mg sale cheap dapsone 100mg cost dapsone 100 mg
https://virtual-local-numbers.com/countries/27-portugal.html
clomid price imuran pill purchase azathioprine sale
https://european-sailing.com/yacht-charter-mauritius
methylprednisolone 16 mg otc order aristocort 10mg pill triamcinolone 10mg us
order vardenafil 20mg pills purchase levitra pill purchase tizanidine for sale
buy dilantin 100 mg sale phenytoin 100mg brand oxybutynin drug
order aceon 8mg sale buy coversyl sale fexofenadine us
baclofen buy online lioresal online order purchase toradol sale
order loratadine generic dapoxetine buy online priligy 90mg without prescription
where can i buy lioresal buy ozobax pill order toradol 10mg without prescription
where to buy fosamax without a prescription how to buy gloperba macrodantin 100 mg cost
inderal over the counter inderal 10mg generic plavix order
pamelor 25 mg us order pamelor online buy acetaminophen 500 mg sale
amaryl cheap order arcoxia 120mg online cost arcoxia 60mg
Вы не ошиблись, все верно
———-
Сиджин 6 (фильм 2019) смотреть онлайн в HD 720 – 1080 хорошем качестве бесплатно
warfarin drug buy paroxetine 10mg metoclopramide 20mg pills
order orlistat 120mg generic diltiazem buy online diltiazem 180mg sale
khelraja in
buy generic famotidine order losartan 50mg without prescription order tacrolimus 1mg online cheap
https://www.cupidoparamayores.com/forum/topic/Choose-the-right-one
order astelin 10 ml for sale irbesartan for sale online irbesartan 150mg drug
buy nexium paypal topamax 200mg generic topamax 200mg cheap
buy allopurinol paypal buy crestor sale rosuvastatin 20mg cost
I consider, that you are not right. I am assured. Let’s discuss it. Write to me in PM, we will communicate.
zantac 150mg generic brand ranitidine 150mg buy celebrex 200mg online
buspar ca order amiodarone 100mg online buy generic cordarone over the counter
buy generic flomax order tamsulosin online simvastatin 10mg over the counter
oral motilium 10mg coreg where to buy buy sumycin 500mg sale
oral spironolactone 100mg finasteride uk proscar 1mg price
help with papers pay essay writing online assignment help
order diflucan 100mg without prescription cipro 500mg us cipro 1000mg tablet
brand aurogra sildenafil mail order usa oral estrace
metronidazole 400mg for sale sulfamethoxazole over the counter purchase cephalexin online
Yes, really. So happens. Let’s discuss this question. Here or in PM.
lamictal 50mg uk minipress 1mg cost nemazole price
cleocin 300mg over the counter brand cleocin 300mg sildenafil 50mg pill
https://www.sexualcase.com/
retin cream ca retin price avanafil 100mg for sale
tamoxifen 20mg over the counter buy cheap betahistine purchase symbicort
https://www.doornight.com/
order cefuroxime generic careprost price order robaxin 500mg
tadacip 20mg drug diclofenac 50mg uk buy indomethacin 75mg for sale
terbinafine 250mg uk free money no deposit casino play poker online for money
order aspirin 75mg aspirin oral online casino game
write my essay help online casinos paying real money gambling casino online
cheap essay writer essays to write cefixime order online
rocaltrol 0.25mg brand calcitriol 0.25 mg oral fenofibrate order online
order trimox 250mg without prescription buy clarithromycin 250mg without prescription biaxin 250mg canada
clonidine 0.1 mg without prescription buy meclizine 25mg pill spiriva 9 mcg pill
buy generic alfuzosin online which heartburn medicine is best alternative painkiller to co codamol
minocycline medication hytrin 1mg us requip without prescription
uksleepingpillsonline.com weight pills that really work buy wegovy without a prescription
buy femara paypal albenza 400mg pill order aripiprazole 30mg online cheap
prescription pills to stop smoking nhs stop smoking advice pain med prescribed online
On your place I would address for the help in search engines.
medroxyprogesterone 10mg over the counter purchase biltricide without prescription order hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg sale
antiviral drug definition alternatives to insulin shots is insulin better than metformin
order generic cyproheptadine 4mg periactin 4 mg ca order ketoconazole 200 mg pill
get fungus clear now list of antifungal drugs popular blood pressure medication recalled
buy cymbalta cymbalta 40mg pills provigil drug
erosion in the duodenal bulb how to stop tachycardia naturally best prescribed medication for uti
buy phenergan paypal stromectol 12mg drug ivermectin generic cream
emergency contraceptive pill online vitamins that increase male libido herbs for stamina in bed
deltasone cheap amoxicillin 250mg tablet order amoxil 500mg generic
supplements to increase stomach mucus hydrochloric acid pills walgreens fart suppression pills
azithromycin over the counter neurontin sale gabapentin buy online