The Sowetan Sunday World (SSW from now on) yesterday (15/07/01) carried a story about a seven-year-old boy child who had been disfigured in a fire. They published a close-up picture of the child and identified him by name. The headline was “Give me a Gun.” A note below the picture and the headline stated, “We publish this picture of Oscar Hadebe knowing it might open us to accusations of insensitivity. We want to illustrate the plight of this beautiful child and appeal for help. The R96 000 already donated is not enough for Oscar’s plastic surgery. Sowetan Sunday World pledge R1000 to Oscar’s trust fund. We urge you to join us. – Editor”
No reason was given as to why the picture was used, either on the front page or in the story on page 6, which is accompanied by another equally dramatic photograph of the child. The central thrust of the story appears to be the extreme suffering the boy child experiences as a result of his appearance. This torment forms the basis for the headline where the pain of the boy is so extreme he wishes he was able to shoot those who laugh at him. The story states, “He had on a hat, which covered most of his face. He hid his face to shield the horrific scars.” They also explain in the story how the child prefers to play indoors so that he doesn’t have to be outside and seen by other children and goes on to note how the boy prefers to play on his own. In spite of this SSW elected to use two clear images of the boy exposing him to significantly more people than those in his neighbourhood.
The efforts of the SSW to raise funds for the boy’s operation are commendable but the SSW are guilty of more than just insensitivity. Section 28(2) of the Constitution states, “a child’s best interests are of paramount importance in every matter concerning the child.” The working document of the Media Code of the Office of the Status of Children in the President’s Office, the World Health Organisation’s Children’s Reporting Guidelines and the International Federation of Journalists Guidelines all emphasise the extreme care and sensitivity and respect for privacy that needs to be shown when dealing with children in the media.
In the present case one may argue that by showing the boy, it may have the desired impact of encouraging people to donate money to the boy’s trust fund and that hence, the story is in his best interests. The validity of such an argument aside, the following aspects need to be considered. The dramatic nature of the story highlighted by its placement on the front page emphasised the drama and not the plight of the boy. There was no discussion of the issue of how many other children are burned in fires. There was no mention of the child’s rights. No regard for the boy’s privacy was shown and no explanation was given for the use of the images. That the best interests of the child were not paramount is further supported by another story on the opposite page.
On page 7, a story is titled, “Hospital of Hell” wherein three children are named and a photograph of one of them is shown. The story is about how each of the children were severely injured during routine medical procedures at the hospital. No clear reasons for naming the children are given. It is even more difficult in this instance to argue that naming and identifying them was in their best interests. Indeed the horror of what happened to them could have been conveyed without naming them.
In spite of the stated intentions of the SSW, these factors suggest scant regard for the interests of the children involved and the violation of their rights to privacy seem difficult to justify. The MMP encourages the media to cover issue such as these but to exercise due regard for their rights when doing so.
brand tricor 160mg buy tricor sale fenofibrate 200mg drug
buy zaditor pills for sale sinequan pill buy tofranil 75mg generic
purchase minoxytop sale mintop for sale online ed pills otc
order acarbose 50mg online order micronase 2.5mg pills how to buy fulvicin
aspirin 75 mg oral aspirin 75mg us imiquimod without prescription
melatonin 3mg us buy melatonin 3 mg generic order danazol
order dydrogesterone 10 mg for sale order empagliflozin 25mg generic buy jardiance pills
buy etodolac pills cilostazol drug oral cilostazol
purchase florinef online buy fludrocortisone without a prescription order generic loperamide 2mg
cost mestinon 60 mg cheap feldene buy generic maxalt 5mg
zovirax us xeloda oral how to get rivastigmine without a prescription
buy enalapril 5mg cheap duphalac buy duphalac paypal
premarin over the counter buy premarin 0.625mg online cheap viagra 50mg sale
cialis 40mg for sale generic cialis cost sildenafil 50mg tablets
provigil order online prednisone 40mg tablet prednisone 20mg pill
isotretinoin 20mg cost buy isotretinoin 20mg online buy generic zithromax
purchase azipro for sale order gabapentin sale cost neurontin 600mg
online casino real money us no deposit free spins casino order furosemide pills
roulette online free order albuterol 4mg generic order ventolin inhalator
internet roulette real money online casinos usa can i buy ivermectin online
real casinos online no deposit augmentin 1000mg pill synthroid tablets
order symmetrel 100 mg pill atenolol brand cost dapsone
clomiphene ca buy clomid without a prescription imuran online buy
vardenafil brand buy zanaflex pill buy generic zanaflex for sale
phenytoin 100mg without prescription buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg pills oxytrol online order
baclofen 10mg drug endep 10mg uk generic toradol 10mg
buy generic baclofen over the counter buy lioresal sale toradol usa
buy generic fosamax over the counter nitrofurantoin without prescription macrodantin us
order inderal generic nurofen ca plavix 150mg pills
buy nortriptyline without a prescription pamelor ca buy anacin 500 mg generic
glimepiride 4mg cheap arcoxia 60mg without prescription arcoxia 120mg tablet
buy coumadin pill buy paroxetine 20mg generic reglan 10mg uk
orlistat order online diltiazem over the counter order diltiazem online cheap
where can i buy famotidine buy cozaar tacrolimus online order
esomeprazole 20mg without prescription esomeprazole 40mg for sale order topiramate 100mg online cheap
buy azelastine cheap irbesartan 300mg uk order avapro 150mg sale
order sumatriptan 25mg pill buy levofloxacin tablets order generic avodart 0.5mg
order zantac 300mg pills buy celebrex no prescription buy celecoxib 100mg sale
oral tamsulosin 0.4mg where can i buy tamsulosin simvastatin 10mg ca
aldactone usa order aldactone 100mg pill order proscar 5mg sale
purchase fluconazole for sale order generic cipro buy cipro online cheap
generic sildenafil 50mg sildalis over the counter cost yasmin
buy flagyl generic buy flagyl 200mg generic buy cheap keflex
cleocin 150mg price erythromycin 250mg pill generic fildena 50mg
buy nolvadex tablets symbicort sale order symbicort online
ceftin order buy cheap cefuroxime order methocarbamol generic
buy desyrel 50mg sale clindamycin sale clindamycin over the counter
purchase aspirin for sale order aspirin 75 mg generic play blackjack online
affordable term papers real online casino free roulette
rocaltrol 0.25 mg pills rocaltrol cheap buy fenofibrate pills
strongest acne over the counter cheap oxcarbazepine 300mg oral oxcarbazepine 600mg
uroxatral 10mg pills medicine for acidic person best prescription drug for nausea
strongest sleeping pills for insomnia adipex online pharmacy diet pills weight pills that really work
free medication to quit smoking arthritis medications list list of strongest pain meds